Here at Live Simply Live More, we’re big believers in second hand shopping. In fact, we think thrift stores should almost always be your first stop when you need something.
Almost.
Because while buying second hand is one of the smartest choices you can make—for your wallet and the planet—there are a few items that you should never buy second hand.
We live in a world of abundance, yet at a time of growing economic uncertainty and ongoing environmental emergencies. Reusing what already exists, instead of producing everything from scratch, is one of the most practical and responsible decisions we can make as consumers.
Shopping second hand saves money and significantly reduces environmental impact. For example, choosing second hand clothing over new can reduce carbon emissions by up to 25%. Reuse lowers demand for water, energy, and raw materials, cuts down on chemical pollution, and keeps usable items out of landfills and incinerators.
That said, even the most eco-conscious, budget-savvy shopper should know when to walk away.
Below are five categories of things that simply aren’t worth the risk and you should never buy second hand—and what to do instead.
Lingerie and Swimsuits
These items come into contact with intimate areas and are extremely difficult to clean thoroughly. For hygiene reasons, it’s best to avoid second hand lingerie and swimsuits unless they are brand new and still have original tags attached.
If you want to save money here, invest in high-quality, ethically made basics that last longer and hold their shape over time.
Fast Fashion Items
Buying second hand fast fashion isn’t wrong—you’re still choosing reuse over new production. However, fast fashion is designed to be low-quality and short-lived, meaning many items won’t survive more than a few wears.
A better approach? Focus on well-made second hand brands, quality fabrics, and classic silhouettes. These pieces age better, last longer, and are a far smarter long-term investment.
Anything That Can’t Be Washed or Properly Cleaned
When you buy second hand, you should assume every item needs cleaning—even if it looks spotless in-store. You never truly know how or where something was used.
That cushion could come from a smoker’s home. That cutting board may not have been properly sanitised. Poor storage can also mean pests, allergens, or lingering toxins.
If an item can’t be thoroughly cleaned or sanitised, it’s not worth bringing home. Choose washable fabrics, solid materials, and low-maintenance surfaces instead.
Anything That Isn’t Safe to Use
Safety standards change over time. Items that were considered safe decades ago may now pose real risks.
Be especially cautious with baby gear, electronics, kitchen tools, and helmets. Always check that items are fully functional and meet current safety regulations. When safety is uncertain, certification and testing matter.
If buying new is unavoidable, look for refurbished, certified, or sustainably made alternatives.
Unsealed Puzzles and Games
These are classic thrift store traps. While you can often spot missing pieces in board games, it’s nearly impossible to guarantee that puzzles or card decks are complete unless they’re sealed in their original packaging.
There’s nothing worse than finishing a puzzle—only to discover a missing piece. For this reason, puzzles and games are usually better bought new rather than preowned.
Thrift Smarter, Not Harder
These are the top five things you should never buy second hand. Thrifting isn’t about saying yes to everything—it’s about making informed, intentional choices. By knowing what to avoid and what to buy instead, you can save money, reduce waste, and still bring home items you’ll love for years.
Keep up the smart thrifting for fewer regrets, better purchases, and a more sustainable lifestyle!
